Introduction
The fresh start effect is people's tendency to start on goals more readily after a new beginning on the calendar: a Monday, a new month, a new quarter, a birthday. Leaders can use it on purpose to reset a team, as long as the reset doesn't erase what their top performers already achieved.
The research behind the effect began with a workplace question. At a Google People and Innovation Lab summit, someone asked Wharton professor Katherine Milkman when the best time would be to help employees change unhealthy habits. Her immediate reaction, as she later recalled, was that it should be when employees are feeling fresh. That hunch led to a study by Milkman, Hengchen Dai and Jason Riis on how the calendar shapes motivation.
What the Research Found
Their 2014 paper in Management Science, "The Fresh Start Effect: Temporal Landmarks Motivate Aspirational Behavior," reports three studies of real-world data. Google searches for the word "diet," gym visits, and commitments to pursue goals on the website stickK all rose after temporal landmarks: the start of a new week, month, year or school semester, birthdays, and holidays.
The effect reaches well beyond New Year's resolutions. Mondays, the first day of a month and the days after holidays were all moments when this kind of aspirational behavior increased.
A follow-up paper in Psychological Science in 2015, "Put Your Imperfections Behind You," by the same three researchers, reported five studies. It found that dates signaling a new beginning make people more motivated to pursue goals because those dates make past failures feel like they belong to an earlier period.
Why a Date Can Change Behavior
The researchers propose that landmarks create breaks in how people perceive time, which leaves them feeling disconnected from their past imperfections. Dai has described fresh starts as helping people separate an older, less capable self from a new, improved one. They also prompt people to step back and look at their lives in a wider frame.
That matters for confidence. Someone weighed down by a missed target tends to carry it into every new attempt. A landmark gives that person permission to treat the miss as part of a finished chapter.
Leaders Can Create Their Own Landmarks
Milkman says landmarks can be big or small, and people can create them for themselves. A team doesn't have to wait for January. A project launch, a reorganization, a kick-off or even a deliberately marked Monday can all serve as a fresh start.
The motivation boost may not last long. But a short burst of motivation is often enough to get a new habit or goal started. That points to two practical uses: nudge people toward new behavior at natural landmarks, when nudges tend to work best, and create turning points on purpose when the team needs one.
When Resets Backfire on Top Performers
A fresh start helps some people more than others. In a 2018 paper in Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, "A Double-Edged Sword: How and Why Resetting Performance Metrics Affects Motivation and Performance," Hengchen Dai ran three experiments and a field study of four decades of batting data from Major League Baseball players who were traded mid-season, when their batting averages effectively reset.
Across the studies, unexpected resets boosted confidence, motivation and later performance for people coming off a weak stretch. For people coming off a strong stretch, the same resets lowered confidence and hurt motivation and performance.
For a leader, that applies to any moment when scores, quotas or rankings go back to zero. The people who struggled get a welcome clean slate. The people who built a lead lose it, and a reset that ignores them can cost the team its strongest contributors. Dai's advice is to recognize that resets don't affect everyone equally, and to frame them accordingly.
How to Use Fresh Starts With a Team
The studies didn't test these steps directly, but they follow from the findings:
Open the week with intention. Start Monday by asking each person to decide what a good week looks like. Juan Bendana makes the same point in one of his notes: decide what a good week looks like before it begins, so you know how to measure it by Friday.
Close the old period before opening the new one. At a quarterly reset, name the closed period, misses included, before the team looks ahead.
Honor the leaders of the last period. At a new quarter or kick-off, acknowledge what top performers achieved so the reset doesn't feel like erasure.
Draw a line after a hard stretch. After a bad run, say plainly that the stretch is over. It's one of the simplest ways to restart a team that has gone flat. As Juan has put it: today is a new day, so stop approaching it through the lens of what happened yesterday.
Where the Evidence Stops
The 2014 studies used real-world records to measure when people start on goals: searching for a diet, visiting a gym, making a commitment. They don't show how long the new behavior lasts, and the goals studied were mostly personal ones. Applying the effect to team performance, quotas and kick-offs is a reasonable extension of the research, and the boost may fade quickly without follow-through. A fresh start opens a window; what the team does in the weeks after decides how much it's worth.
Make Your Next Kick-Off a Real Fresh Start
Juan Bendana's keynote Make Confidence Your Competitive Advantage helps leaders set clear, actionable goals and turn today's barriers into tomorrow's breakthroughs. It's designed for sales kick-offs, annual meetings and high-performance teams, which are fresh starts for most organizations, as well as leadership conferences and corporate events where a new period is about to begin.
Start a conversation with Juan Bendana's team about turning your next kick-off into a fresh start your whole team can use.
A new period only helps the people who are given a reason to believe it can go differently.